Scammers are selling seeds for plants that don\u2019t exist with spectacular, AI-generated images of technicolor leaves that bloom in the shape of birds, butterflies, and cat heads. This type of fake seeds scam predates widespread access to AI image generators, but the ability to easily create these images has made the scam more widespread, especially on big online retailers like eBay, Amazon, and Etsy, which are unable to keep up with the flood of scam plant sellers on their platforms.\u00a0The type of images scammers use to sell seeds online range from slightly exaggerated aesthetics to full-blown, obviously fake AI slop that looks like it was rejected from Avatar\u2019s alien jungle.\u00a0One common scam seed is for a sunflower variety called \u2018teddy bear,\u2019 named after its poofy, fluffy appearance. You can see what it looks like in reality on the Royal Horticultural Society\u2019s website. Spectacular, yes, but that is nothing compared to the AI-generated images of gigantic, purple teddy bear sunflowers on Etsy:This Etsy store, which sells a wide selection of seeds for real plants with AI-generated images, and which also randomly sells AI-generated Trump T-shirts, has mixed reviews, with some buyers saying the seeds look healthy, and others complaining they never got their shipment, or that they received seeds for the wrong plant.\u00a0At least dozens of sellers on eBay and Amazon also offer seeds for plants they promote with clearly AI-generated images. Searching the stores for \u201csunflower teddy bear seeds\u201d returns many such images, including identical images to those I found on Etsy. For some reason, AI-generated images for teddy bear sunflowers often feature a random old lady next to the gigantic flowers (grandma for scale?).On the more obviously fake end of the spectrum is basically anything sold on Etsy by Trenzay. For example, this hosta plant that looks like a bunch of screaming demon shrimps:\u00a0This plant that looks like a butterfly:Or this very patriotic, red, white, and blue plant:\u201cRose seeds\u201d and \u201crainbow seeds\u201d are two of the more common types of fake plants promoted with AI-generated images, probably because the rainbow-colored leaves and bushes are eye-catching. To me, they seem obviously, laughably AI-generated, but their popularity and public facing data from some online retailers indicate people have bought them thousands of times. This is reflected not only in user reviews who claim the sellers are scammers, but also by the number of units sold, which is sometimes shown on eBay.\u00a0\ud83c\udf38Do you know anything else about these seed scams? I would love to hear from you. You can message me securely on Signal at \u202a@emanuel.404\u202c. Otherwise, send me an email at emanuel@404media.co.In 2024 I wrote a story about Google serving users AI-generated images of mushrooms, which could potentially have dangerous consequences for users who are using Google to decide whether a mushroom is safe to eat. A moderator of the r\/mycology Reddit community told me at the time that at some point, scams for exotic rose seeds were so common that Google image search results for that term turned up AI-generated or photoshopped images of fake flowers almost exclusively.\u00a0Seeds for these clearly fake, colorful roses sold 37,271 times on eBay before eBay banned the seller:Seeds for these gigantic, fake teddy bear sunflowers sold 1,301 times (AI-generated grandma not included):\u00a0\u201cThese listings have remained unchanged for years. It is a profitable business to sell fake seeds since there is no cost involved beyond an envelope and postage, a plastic bag and a few hours to collect random seeds,\u201d the r\/mycology moderator told me at the time. \u201cThe selling price may be low but enough people buy them to make it add up.\u201d<\/p>\n
Tip Jar<\/p>\n
The fake seed scam is not limited to the dominant online retailers either. On Reddit and Facebook, plant enthusiasts warn each other about shady sites dedicated to selling seeds that offer the same fake plants.In addition to confusing search engines about what real plants look like, the risk to people ordering seeds for a fake plant is that they\u2019re not going to get what they want and waste their money. The seeds might sprout an entirely different plant than the one advertised, or not sprout at all.\u00a0The bigger problem is that if people don\u2019t realize that they\u2019re planting seeds for an entirely different plant than the one they ordered, they could unknowingly introduce invasive species to their environment. Last year, three states issued warnings against planting seeds they received in the mail as part of a widespread scam popularized around 2020, in which people were sent unsolicited packets of mystery seeds that sellers then used to write bogus online reviews for unrelated items.<\/p>\n
\u201cTrust is foundational to eBay\u2019s marketplace and we have policies and controls in place to help detect and prevent fraudulent activity on our marketplace, including misleading AI-generated images that violate our listing practices policy,\u201d an eBay spokesperson told me in an email. \u201cWe work diligently to prevent and remove non-compliant listings through seller compliance audits, block filter algorithms, AI-supported monitoring by in-house specialists, and through close partnerships with regulators. We continue to invest in tools and technologies and we encourage users to report suspicious activity and, where we identify behavior that violates our policies, we take appropriate action.\u201dEtsy and Amazon did not respond to a request for comment. <\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"